Subject: Re: [drugwar] Manhattan City Hall Smoking Ban rally on 24th Date: Wed, 16 Jul 2003 09:24:35 -0400 To: From: Bob Armstrong On Wed, 16 Jul 2003 05:43:11 -0700 (PDT), Libby wrote: >=A0NYC is not about >=A0over-amped music in a club or people who are >=A0inconsiderate to their neighbors with their hi-tech >=A0home electronics, it's about the 15 minutes it takes >=A0for the bar patrons to disburse at closing time. It is about the smokers who can no longer smoke inside the bar so hang around outside taking a puff . Even most of that complaining is BS . And , yes , there are those dangerous complainers who move into areas or above bars and then bitch about noise , etc . I live right at the Fulton Fish Market and I love it because it is more alive from 2 to 5 than just about anywhere else . I always figured if I really needed to sleep , nothing would keep me awake . My lullaby is fork lifts . Incidentally , property rights are a cornerstone of libertarian belief . Externalities , like noise , are an appropriate thing to bitch about - unless preexisting . More consequentially , logically the State might appropriately control , eg , smoking , in the "commons" , the streets and sidewalks , but have absolutely NO right to control such things in private spaces such as bars . The guy who owns it or pays the rent is in charge in his own space . --=A0 =A0Bob Armstrong -- http://CoSy.com -- 212-285-1864 42 Peck Slip , 10038 -- 2003/07/16 9:04:32 AM